Frozen pizza has come a long way from its humble beginnings as a quick and convenient meal. With so many options on the market, choosing the best frozen pizza can be overwhelming.
To make it easier for you, we tried and ranked 17 of the best frozen pizzas, tasting everything from classic cheese to pepperoni and veggie options. After careful consideration of flavor, texture, and overall pizza experience, we found a winner that truly had us shook.
17. Totino’s Party Pizza
Totino’s Party Pizza is a nostalgic favorite for many, but when it comes to taste and texture, it leaves a lot to be desired. The crust is more akin to a cracker, and the toppings are thin and not particularly flavorful. While it’s a cheap and quick fix for a pizza craving, it ranks low on this list due to its lackluster flavor profile and minimal cheese.
16. Red Baron Classic Crust Pepperoni
Red Baron is a well-known name in the frozen pizza world, but their Classic Crust Pepperoni pizza doesn’t stand out. The crust is a bit too thick and bready, while the sauce is on the sweeter side, which may not appeal to everyone. The pepperoni adds some flavor, but overall, the pizza is average and doesn’t leave a lasting impression.
15. Amy’s Margherita Pizza
Amy’s is known for its organic and healthier frozen options, but their Margherita Pizza falls a bit flat. While the ingredients are high-quality and the cheese is fresh, the crust tends to be soggy, and the flavor isn’t as bold as some of the other options. It’s a solid choice if you’re looking for a cleaner pizza, but it doesn’t pack the flavor punch you might expect.
14. DiGiorno Rising Crust Four Cheese
DiGiorno’s Rising Crust Four Cheese pizza is well-known for its thick, fluffy crust that rises as it bakes. However, the crust can sometimes overshadow the rest of the pizza, leaving you with more bread than toppings. The cheese blend is decent, but it’s not the most flavorful pizza in the lineup. It’s a filling choice, but the balance of crust to toppings isn’t ideal.
13. Trader Joe’s Organic Roasted Vegetable Pizza
Trader Joe’s offers a wide variety of frozen pizzas, and their Organic Roasted Vegetable Pizza stands out for its fresh ingredients and bold flavors. The roasted veggies give it a nice, earthy flavor, but the thin crust can get soggy if not cooked properly. It’s a great option for veggie lovers, though not the most traditional pizza experience.
12. Freschetta Brick Oven Crust Pepperoni
Freschetta’s Brick Oven Crust Pepperoni pizza offers a better crust-to-topping ratio than some of the thicker-crust options. The pepperoni is flavorful, and the cheese has a nice melt, but the sauce is on the milder side. It’s a solid, middle-of-the-pack pizza that delivers on taste but doesn’t exceed expectations.
11. Newman’s Own Thin & Crispy Pizza
Newman’s Own is known for using high-quality, organic ingredients, and their Thin & Crispy Pizza delivers on that promise. The crust is delightfully crunchy, and the flavors are clean and well-balanced. However, the thin crust can leave you wanting more, especially if you prefer a heartier pizza.
10. Tombstone Original 4 Cheese
Tombstone’s Original 4 Cheese pizza brings nostalgia and a good balance of cheese and sauce. The crust has a nice chew without being too thick, and the cheese blend is flavorful. It’s a solid option if you’re looking for something that feels more like a classic frozen pizza but with a little extra flavor.
9. California Pizza Kitchen BBQ Chicken
California Pizza Kitchen (CPK) has brought its restaurant-quality flavors to the frozen aisle with their BBQ Chicken pizza. The sweet and tangy barbecue sauce paired with tender chicken makes for a unique pizza experience. While not traditional, it’s a flavorful and interesting option for when you want something different.
8. Screamin’ Sicilian Bessie’s Revenge
Screamin’ Sicilian is known for its bold flavors and generous toppings, and Bessie’s Revenge doesn’t disappoint. This cheese lover’s dream is loaded with different varieties of cheese, offering a rich, gooey experience. The crust is thick but balances the heavy toppings, making it a satisfying option for those who want an indulgent pizza.
7. Dr. Oetker Ristorante Mozzarella Pizza
Dr. Oetker’s Ristorante Mozzarella Pizza brings an Italian-style pizza experience to your freezer. The thin, crispy crust is light, and the fresh mozzarella adds a luxurious touch. The flavor is more subtle compared to other pizzas on this list, but it’s perfect for those who enjoy a more refined, European-style pizza.
6. Whole Foods 365 Thin Crust Pepperoni
Whole Foods’ 365 Thin Crust Pepperoni pizza offers great value and quality for a frozen pizza. The crust is thin and crispy, with a good amount of pepperoni and just the right balance of sauce and cheese. It’s a reliable option if you’re looking for something affordable and delicious from a grocery store.
5. Palermo’s Primo Thin
Palermo’s Primo Thin pizza offers a crisp, cracker-like crust that’s light and airy. The toppings are fresh and flavorful, and the pizza doesn’t feel greasy, making it one of the best thin-crust options on the market. It’s great for when you want a quick, flavorful pizza without the heaviness of thicker crusts.
4. Against the Grain Gourmet Pizza
For those who are gluten-free, Against the Grain offers one of the best options on the market. Their pizza doesn’t sacrifice flavor or texture despite being gluten-free. The crust is chewy and satisfying, and the cheese and sauce are flavorful, making it a great option even for those without dietary restrictions.
3. Gino’s East Deep Dish
If you’re a fan of deep-dish pizza, Gino’s East delivers one of the best frozen versions out there. The thick, buttery crust holds up well, and the gooey cheese and tangy sauce are perfectly balanced. It’s a bit more time-consuming to cook, but the result is worth it for deep-dish lovers.
2. Motor City Pizza Co. 5 Cheese Bread Pizza
Motor City Pizza Co. has made a name for itself with its Detroit-style frozen pizzas. The 5 Cheese Bread Pizza has a thick, fluffy crust with a crispy edge, and the cheese-to-sauce ratio is just right. The bold flavors and indulgent texture make it a standout option, second only to our winner.
1. Newman’s Own Thin & Crispy Supreme Pizza
The winner of the frozen pizza taste test is Newman’s Own Thin & Crispy Supreme Pizza. This pizza checks all the boxes: a perfectly crispy crust, a generous amount of toppings, and a flavorful sauce. The vegetables are fresh, and the pepperoni adds a nice kick.
It’s everything you want from a frozen pizza, and the fact that the profits go to charity makes it even better. This pizza truly had us shook with its delicious, well-balanced flavor.
Final Thoughts
Frozen pizza is a staple in many households, but with so many options on the market, it’s important to know which ones deliver the best experience. From the nostalgia of Totino’s to the gourmet flavors of Newman’s Own, this ranking offers something for every pizza lover.
Whether you’re a fan of thin crust, deep dish, or something in between, there’s a frozen pizza on this list that will satisfy your cravings.